Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

Reviews

• Kennedy U.

  star star star star star 9 June 2026

  So nice to have a good pizza joint close by! The staff is always friendly and the wait times are never bad, even when they are busy. Not to mention the pizza is ALWAYS fantastic. One of the more consistent restaurants in the area and they're deliveries are always reliable. Would recommend to people in the Lakewood area.

• Court R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  First I must say I've been ordering from this location for a long time and have never had any problems until tonight...
  If this app would allow less stars they would get none after tonight's ridiculous phone conversation with two immature, untrained and incredibly unprofessional employees. After a misunderstanding about an awful order costing only $15, they refused to apologize about the wrong order to start. They refused to offer compensation or a remake at all. They refused to remake 4 slices of pizza for us after waiting well over an hour for delivery and when discussing the problem the girl put us on hold to answer another phone call in the middle of ours.
  
  I will never come back to this location. If I ever ever treated a customer like this at my job I would be fired in a second. Such a shame they get away with this kind of service.

• Julie R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 28 May 2026

  After calling to complain about an order that was absolutely unacceptable I can honestly tell you that I will never order from this location again. The customer service is horrible. I am totally disappointed and feel completely unheard. To the two separate people that I spoke to, being a long term customer should matter to you. Clearly it does not. I hope that the owner of this store is aware of this review. You just lost a customer that cared.  Your attitudes are a clear example of what is wrong in this world.

• Roy S.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  Ordered takeout. We requested if we could have the cheese bread early. Well 8-10 later should she forgot to tell the cooks. Needless to say she said it would be done in 6 minutes. While waiting...the restaurant we noticed almost all the tables have not been cleaned. Flies were everywhere! Really bad. The little teenager should of been cleaning! She is definitely not a people person!  Note the cheese bread can out 15 minutes later with our pizza! We sat down to eat the cheese bread she was still on her phone. She said here is your pizza. I said nothing and she replied "your welcome"! I said look I wanted my cheese bread early and she said "I'm not part of the kitchen ". There was no I'm sorry for forgetting your cheese bread.
  This will be the last time here!

• Kim M.

  star star star star star_border 16 May 2026

  Anthony's has pretty good NY cheese pizza. The pizzas are large and the take out times have never been very long for us (30 minutes max). The fettuccini alfredo isn't too bad either! Salads are typical but always fresh. It's nice to have a local pizza spot!